El ColegiadoData on refereeing in the Liga

Carlos Velasco Carballo × Francisco Puñal

21 matches of Francisco Puñal (CA Osasuna) refereed by Carlos Velasco Carballo, from 2004-05 to 2013-14.

Report an error on this pageHow to read this page
Player data: 2000-01 → 2021-22 only. Player-level match sheets come from Zenodo (BeSoccer, CC BY-NC 4.0 licence, non-commercial use). No free source provides them after 2021-22: more recent matches are not counted here. Penalties conceded are not attributed to players in the source, so they are not analysed.

In short

Carlos Velasco Carballo refereed 21 Liga matches in which Francisco Puñal took part, from 2004-05 to 2013-14: 1,662 minutes played, 8 yellow cards and 1 red cards. With the other referees, over the same seasons (293 matches, 23,008 minutes), Francisco Puñal receives 0.40 yellow cards per 90 minutes, against 0.43 with Carlos Velasco Carballo.

Verdict: no clear difference with the other referees.

Cards are rare (less than one per player per match): over a few dozen matches, only a very large deviation can be told apart from chance. "No clear difference" does not mean "no effect".

Matches

21

19 starts · 1,662 minutes · 10 seasons

Yellow cards

8for 7.5 expected

0.43 per 90 minutes with this referee · 0.40 with the others

no clear difference

Red cards

1for 0.3 expected

0.05 per 90 minutes with this referee · 0.02 with the others

no clear difference
For experts: statistical tests and method

Permutation test stratified by season: within each season, the player's matches given to this referee are drawn again at random among all the player's matches (same number per season). Deviation = (observed − expected cards) per 90 minutes played with this referee; positive = more cards than expected. q: Benjamini-Hochberg correction over the 3,781 pairs with at least 10 matches, separately for yellows and reds.

MeasureObservedExpectedDeviation / 90 minpqVerdict
Yellow cards87.53+0.0260.811.00no clear difference
Red cards10.31+0.0380.181.00no clear difference

The 21 matches

Minutes played and cards received by Francisco Puñal in each match refereed by Carlos Velasco Carballo.

DateMatchTeamMinutesYellowsReds
17 Oct 2004CA Osasuna 3-2 Albacete BalompiéCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
2 Mar 2005Albacete Balompié 1-1 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
5 Nov 2005Real Sociedad 1-2 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
5 Nov 2006Sevilla FC 2-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 66′10
26 Aug 2007Athletic Bilbao 0-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
23 Mar 2008CA Osasuna 0-1 Real BetisCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
8 Feb 2009CA Osasuna 1-0 Valencia CFCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
16 May 2009CA Osasuna 0-0 Sevilla FCCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
13 Sept 2009CD Tenerife 2-1 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
22 Nov 2009CA Osasuna 1-3 Valencia CFCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
24 Mar 2010FC Barcelona 2-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′10
21 Sept 2010CA Osasuna 3-1 Real SociedadCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
31 Oct 2010Racing de Santander 4-1 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
1 May 2011CA Osasuna 1-0 Valencia CFCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
1 Oct 2011CA Osasuna 2-2 RCD MallorcaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
18 Feb 2012Sevilla FC 2-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
10 Apr 2012CA Osasuna 2-0 RCD EspanyolCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
21 Oct 2012CA Osasuna 0-0 Real BetisCA Osasuna0′ → 90′00
13 Apr 2013Málaga CF 1-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna↑ 64′ → 90′10
1 Dec 2013Valencia CF 3-0 CA OsasunaCA Osasuna0′ → 17′01
26 Jan 2014CA Osasuna 1-5 Athletic BilbaoCA Osasuna↑ 67′ → 90′00

↑: came on as a substitute. Stoppage time is not recorded in the source: minutes stop at 90.

Francisco Puñal with other referees

  • César Muñiz Fernández20 matches
  • Pérez Lasa20 matches
  • Iturralde González17 matches
  • Fernando Teixeira Vitienes16 matches
  • David Fernández Borbalán15 matches
  • Luis Medina Cantalejo15 matches
  • Manuel Mejuto González15 matches
  • Ramírez Domínguez15 matches
  • Antonio Rubinos Pérez15 matches
  • Javier Turienzo Álvarez15 matches
  • Carlos Megía Dávila14 matches
  • Alfonso Pérez Burrull14 matches
  • Bernardino González Vázquez13 matches
  • Alfonso Álvarez12 matches
  • Ayza Gámez12 matches
  • Arturo Daudén Ibáñez12 matches
  • José Paradas Romero12 matches
  • González González11 matches
  • Julián Rodríguez Santiago11 matches