El ColegiadoData on refereeing in the Liga

Study

Negreira case: before / during / after

What the numbers say about refereeing before, during and after the payments.

  • 2000-01 → 2025-26
  • 9,880 matches
  • Updated on 17 October 2026
  • Method

In short

The facts
Between 2001 and 2018, FC Barcelona paid money to companies linked to José María Enríquez Negreira, then vice-president of the referees' committee (CTA).
The courts
As of 1 September 2026 (EFE via Infobae; The Objective), the case is still at the investigation stage (instrucción) before Barcelona Investigating Court No. 1 (Juzgado de Instrucción n.º 1; Judge Alejandra Gil Lima): the judge refused a further extension requested by Real Madrid and supported by the Public Prosecutor's Office, but the investigation phase will not be closed before two witness statements scheduled for 13 November 2026, and an appeal concerning investigative measures remains pending before the Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial). No referee has been charged as of 2 October 2026.
The referees
Of 1,336 referee × club pairs analysed, none deviates more than chance explains, once team strength is taken into account.
Barça
Between the payment years and afterwards, Barça's points (relative to the odds) change in the same way as Atlético's, Valencia's and Sevilla's: no clear difference.
A signal to qualify
Compared with Real Madrid, fouls and yellow cards changed clearly after 2018. But playing style, VAR and the end of the payments all happen at the same time: they cannot be separated.

Everyone mentioned is presumed innocent; a statistical deviation is not proof.

Payment period

2001 → 2018

17 Liga seasons

Barça vs control group, points − expected

−0.111

Difference-in-differences per match, q = 0.27: no clear difference

Notable referee × club deviations

0

out of 1,336 pairs tested, after correction

Dated events

49

As of 2 October 2026

Key takeaways

  1. 0 notable referee × club deviations after correction, out of 1,336 pairs tested (2000-01 → 2025-26). See
  2. Barça against the control group, points − expected: −0.111 per match between "during" (2001-18) and "after" (2018-26), q = 0.27: no clear difference. See
  3. Adjusted fouls and yellows: raw p 0.02 and 0.08, but q = 0.08 and 0.24 after correction: no clear difference. See
  4. A referee × club pair has a median of 11 matches: only deviations of about ±1.57 points per match were detectable. See
  5. Compared with Real Madrid, the fouls and yellow-card balance moved notably after 2018 (q < 0.001 – 0.04): Barça's advantage shrank while Real Madrid's grew. This is not the case against the control group (q = 0.08 to 0.27). Playing style, VAR (2018-19) and the end of the payments coincide and cannot be separated. See
  6. No referee prosecuted as of 2 October 2026; payments from 2001 to 2018. See

Status of the proceedings as of 2 October 2026: As of 1 September 2026 (EFE via Infobae; The Objective), the case is still at the investigation stage (instrucción) before Barcelona Investigating Court No. 1 (Juzgado de Instrucción n.º 1; Judge Alejandra Gil Lima): the judge refused a further extension requested by Real Madrid and supported by the Public Prosecutor's Office, but the investigation phase will not be closed before two witness statements scheduled for 13 November 2026, and an appeal concerning investigative measures remains pending before the Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial). Full timeline

Keep in mind: Everyone mentioned is presumed innocent; a statistical deviation is not proof. VAR arrives in 2018-19, the same season the payments end. All limitations

Context

Between 2001 and 2018, FC Barcelona paid money to companies linked to José María Enríquez Negreira, then vice-president of the referees' committee (CTA). The Spanish courts are investigating the case; no referee is being prosecuted.

Established facts, court decisions, allegations and ongoing proceedings are kept apart; each event links to its sources.

Frequently asked questions

Who is Negreira?

José María Enríquez Negreira is a former referee who was vice-president of the RFEF's Technical Committee of Referees (CTA) until 2018. Companies linked to him received payments from FC Barcelona. See the sourced timeline.

What is the Negreira case?

Between 2001 and 2018, FC Barcelona paid money to companies linked to José María Enríquez Negreira, then vice-president of the referees' committee (CTA). The Spanish courts are investigating the case; no referee is being prosecuted. The site compares those years with refereeing data, without presuming anything.

What period do the payments cover?

From 2001 to 2018. The site compares three periods: before (2000-01), during (2001-02 → 2017-18) and after (2018-19 → 2025-26); see the statistics by period.

Is there a conviction or a trial date?

As of 2 October 2026, there has been no conviction and the case is still at the investigation stage: As of 1 September 2026 (EFE via Infobae; The Objective), the case is still at the investigation stage (instrucción) before Barcelona Investigating Court No. 1 (Juzgado de Instrucción n.º 1; Judge Alejandra Gil Lima): the judge refused a further extension requested by Real Madrid and supported by the Public Prosecutor's Office, but the investigation phase will not be closed before two witness statements scheduled for 13 November 2026, and an appeal concerning investigative measures remains pending before the Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial). The dated details are under "Status of the proceedings".

Has any referee been charged?

No. As of 2 October 2026, no referee is being prosecuted in this case; everyone mentioned is presumed innocent.

Do the data show that referees favoured Barcelona?

No referee × club deviation remains notable after correction for multiple testing (1,336 pairs tested). These tests have limited power: with a median of 11 matches, only deviations of about ±1.57 points per match could be detected. Over the payment period, the only signals concern fouls and yellow cards (raw p 0.02 and 0.08); they do not survive the correction (q = 0.08 and 0.24). Compared with Real Madrid, the fouls and yellow-card balance moved notably after 2018 (q < 0.001 – 0.04): Barça's advantage shrank while Real Madrid's grew. This is not the case against the control group (q = 0.08 to 0.27). Playing style, VAR (2018-19) and the end of the payments coincide and cannot be separated. See the verdicts

Where does the data come from?

Scores and odds from football-data.co.uk, referees and cards from Zenodo (BeSoccer) and Wikipedia, cross-checked; everything can be downloaded from the Data page and the method is published in the methodology.

Timeline

49 events shown

1994

  1. Established fact

    Negreira becomes vice-president of the CTA

    Institutional

    José María Enríquez Negreira, a former referee, served as vice-president of the Comité Técnico de Árbitros (CTA), the RFEF body responsible for refereeing, from 1994 to 2018, under the presidency of Victoriano Sánchez Arminio. The CTA's duties include assessing referees and deciding on promotions and relegations between categories.

    Sources (3)

2001

  1. Established fact

    FC Barcelona's payments begin

    Payments

    According to the complaint filed by the Public Prosecutor's Office (Fiscalía), FC Barcelona began in 2001 to pay sums to companies linked to Negreira (mainly Dasnil 95 SL, as well as Nilsad SCP). The payments continued under the presidencies of Gaspart, Laporta, Rosell and Bartomeu.

    Sources (2)

2016

  1. Established fact

    2016-2018 payments broken down by company

    Payments

    For 2016-2018, the reported amounts are: Dasnil 95 SL (Negreira's company) approximately €1.39 million (€532,728 in 2016, €541,752 in 2017, €318,200 in 2018); Nilsad SCP, a single payment of €50,000 in 2016; Soccercam SL, a company belonging to his son Javier Enríquez, €450,120 invoiced to the club.

    Sources (2)

2018

  1. Established fact

    Payments stop

    Payments

    The club stopped its payments in 2018, at the time of Negreira's departure from the CTA. Former president Josep Maria Bartomeu has stated that he ended them to cut costs. The exact month of the last payment varies between sources (May or June 2018).

    Sources (2)
  2. Established fact

    End of Negreira's term at the CTA

    Institutional

    After his election as RFEF president in May 2018, Luis Rubiales announced the replacement of the CTA leadership (Sánchez Arminio and his team, including Negreira). Carlos Velasco Carballo became CTA president.

    Sources (3)

2019

  1. Allegation

    Negreira's letter to President Bartomeu

    Payments

    According to press reports published in February 2023, in February 2019, after the payments had stopped, Negreira sent a letter to Josep Maria Bartomeu referring to possible revelations about club "irregularities". The exact content of these irregularities has not been established.

    Sources (1)
  2. Established fact

    Tax audit of FC Barcelona

    Investigation

    The Spanish Tax Agency (Hacienda) opened an audit of FC Barcelona covering corporate income tax (2015-2018) and VAT (2015-2017), during which the invoices from Negreira's companies came to light. This audit is the origin of the criminal case.

    Sources (2)

2021

  1. Established fact

    Negreira's statement to Hacienda

    Investigation

    Heard by the Tax Agency in October 2021, Negreira stated, according to documents reported by the press, that the club wanted "everything to be neutral" and described his work as technical refereeing analyses. According to the press, the Tax Agency indicated that it could not establish that these payments had influenced referee appointments or results.

    Sources (2)

2023

  1. Established fact

    Revelation by Cadena SER

    Investigation

    The programme "Què t'hi jugues" on Cadena SER Catalunya revealed that the Public Prosecutor's Office was investigating payments of approximately €1.4 million made by FC Barcelona to Dasnil 95 SL between 2016 and 2018, while Negreira was vice-president of the CTA.

    Sources (2)
  2. Established fact

    FC Barcelona's position: technical reports

    Statement

    The club acknowledged the payments and stated that it had paid an external consultant for video reports on young players and technical reports on professional refereeing intended for the coaching staff, a practice it presented as common. It denied any attempt to influence referees.

    Sources (2)
  3. Established fact

    LaLiga invokes the sporting statute of limitations

    Sporting

    LaLiga president Javier Tebas stated that no sporting disciplinary sanction was possible because the facts were time-barred (three-year limitation period), while considering that such facts should not occur. The criminal route remains separate.

    Sources (2)
  4. Established fact

    Statement by LaLiga and the clubs

    Statement

    LaLiga's executive committee, backed by almost all the clubs, described the case as extremely serious, said it had passed information to the Public Prosecutor's Office and undertook to act within the scope of its legal powers.

    Sources (1)
  5. Established fact

    Complaint by a referee, Xavier Estrada Fernández

    Court proceedings

    Referee Xavier Estrada Fernández filed a complaint for sporting corruption against Negreira, his son and Dasnil 95 SL. It was later admitted by the court together with that of the Public Prosecutor's Office.

    Sources (2)
  6. Established fact

    LaLiga announces it will join the proceedings as a party

    Institutional

    Javier Tebas announced that LaLiga would join the proceedings as a party (acusación), considering that the reputation of the competition takes precedence over that of any club.

    Sources (1)
  7. Allegation

    Complaint by the Fiscalía

    Court proceedings

    The Barcelona Public Prosecutor's Office filed a complaint against FC Barcelona (as a legal entity), former presidents Sandro Rosell and Josep Maria Bartomeu, former executives Òscar Grau and Albert Soler, and Negreira, for private-to-private corruption in sport (continuing offence), unfair administration (administración desleal) and falsification of commercial documents (falsedad en documento mercantil). According to the Fiscalía, the payments amounted to €7.3 million (2001-2018) and were made under a confidential verbal agreement aimed at favouring the club in refereeing decisions; those concerned dispute this interpretation. The complaint does not target any referee.

    Sources (2)
  8. Established fact

    Real Madrid decides to join the proceedings as a party

    Institutional

    Real Madrid's board of directors announced its intention to join the proceedings, expressing its "deep concern". Its participation as a private prosecutor (acusación particular) was accepted in May 2023.

    Sources (2)
  9. Court decision

    Barcelona Investigating Court No. 1 admits the complaint

    Court proceedings

    Barcelona Investigating Court No. 1 (Juzgado de Instrucción n.º 1) admitted the Public Prosecutor's Office's complaint as well as that of Xavier Estrada, accepted LaLiga as a party and assigned the criminal police investigation (policía judicial) to the Guardia Civil.

    Sources (2)
  10. Established fact

    Joan Laporta's press conference

    Statement

    President Joan Laporta stated that the club had never sought to alter the competition and presented more than 600 reports and CDs intended to document the services provided.

    Sources (1)
  11. Court decision

    Negreira's son placed under investigation

    Court proceedings

    The investigating judge named Javier Enríquez Romero, Negreira's son, as a person under investigation (investigado) and extended the investigation to money laundering, with the proceedings declared secret (secreto de sumario).

    Sources (2)
  12. Court decision

    Judge Aguirre adds bribery of a public official (cohecho)

    Court proceedings

    Judge Joaquín Aguirre attributed the offence of bribery (cohecho) to FC Barcelona and the other persons under investigation, considering that Negreira performed public functions at the CTA. The Public Prosecutor's Office opposes this legal classification.

    Sources (2)
  13. Court decision

    Joan Laporta placed under investigation

    Court proceedings

    Judge Aguirre named Joan Laporta as a person under investigation for bribery (cohecho) in respect of payments made during his first term (2003-2010), considering that the limitation period had not expired. The Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, which had left him out of its complaint, subsequently requested that the case against him be dismissed.

    Sources (2)

2024

  1. Court decision

    RFEF admitted as a party

    Institutional

    The Barcelona Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial) ordered that the RFEF be admitted as a private prosecutor (acusación particular) in the proceedings; the federation had announced in March 2023 that it wished to join them.

    Sources (2)
  2. Court decision

    The Audiencia annuls the cohecho imputation

    Court proceedings

    The Barcelona Provincial Court (Section 21), in line with the Public Prosecutor's Office and the defence, held that Negreira cannot be considered a public official, since sports federations are private entities; the offence of bribery (cohecho) was therefore ruled out.

    Sources (2)
  3. Court decision

    Laporta removed from the case

    Court proceedings

    The Barcelona Audiencia ends the proceedings against Joan Laporta: payments made during his first term (2003-2010) are held to have been time-barred since 2015 for unfair administration (administración desleal), document forgery and sports corruption.

    Sources (2)
  4. Allegation

    Guardia Civil report and Negreira's wife placed under investigation

    Investigation

    According to a Guardia Civil report, the invoiced services are not supported by any documentary evidence beyond the invoices (an assessment by the investigators, disputed by the club). On 28 August 2024, the judge named Negreira's wife as a person under investigation for money laundering after the discovery of approximately €2.98 million in deposits deemed unjustified in her accounts (1992-2023).

    Sources (2)
  5. Allegation

    Guardia Civil puts the payments at €8.4 million

    Investigation

    According to a Guardia Civil report submitted to the judge, the total transfers from the club to companies linked to Negreira between 2001 and 2018 would amount to €8.4 million (135 transfers), compared with €7.3 million in the Public Prosecutor's Office's complaint.

    Sources (1)

2025

  1. Established fact

    Statements by Rosell and Bartomeu

    Court proceedings

    Heard as persons under investigation, Sandro Rosell attributed the club's success to its squad and described the payments as consultancy; Josep Maria Bartomeu said they were inherited from previous administrations and were stopped for budgetary reasons. Both denied seeking any refereeing favours.

    Sources (1)
  2. Court decision

    The club summoned as a legal entity under investigation

    Court proceedings

    The judge summoned FC Barcelona as a legal entity under investigation for a continuing offence of business corruption, requested the original contracts with Dasnil 95 and Nilsad (2001-2014) and called as witnesses, among others, Joan Gaspart, Joan Laporta, Luis Enrique and Ernesto Valverde.

    Sources (2)
  3. Established fact

    Testimony of Laporta, Luis Enrique and Valverde

    Court proceedings

    Heard as a witness, Joan Laporta described the payments as inherited and justified by the usefulness of the reports, denied any refereeing favours and said the club had handed over 629 reports. Former coaches Luis Enrique and Ernesto Valverde said they had not seen or used these reports.

    Sources (2)
  4. Established fact

    Referees point out that none of them is being prosecuted

    Statement

    In response to remarks by the Real Madrid president, the referees' association AESAF pointed out that no referee is under investigation or the subject of an inquiry in the case. No reliable source consulted reports any referee being prosecuted as of 2 October 2026.

    Sources (2)

2026

  1. Established fact

    Testimony of Joan Gaspart

    Court proceedings

    Former president Joan Gaspart (2000-2003), heard as a witness, stated that the club had committed no illegality and that major clubs commonly use observers' reports.

    Sources (1)
  2. Established fact

    Javier Tebas: "Barça did not buy referees"

    Statement

    In a press interview, the LaLiga president said he believed the club had not paid referees, while maintaining that LaLiga remains a party to the proceedings and that the conduct would have warranted a sporting sanction had it not been time-barred.

    Sources (1)
  3. Established fact

    New forensic medical examination of Negreira

    Court proceedings

    At the request of his defence, Negreira, aged 80, was examined again by the Institute of Legal Medicine of Catalonia to assess the progression of his cognitive disorders.

    Sources (1)
  4. Established fact

    The club heard as a legal entity

    Court proceedings

    Represented by its treasurer Alfons Castro, FC Barcelona told the judge that it complies with its obligations and has strengthened its internal controls since 2010. First-team delegate Carles Naval, heard as a witness, said he had received and kept the reports since 2014 without knowing whether they were used.

    Sources (2)
  5. Ongoing

    Expert report: Negreira unfit to follow the proceedings

    Court proceedings

    A report by the Institute of Legal Medicine of Catalonia concluded that Negreira no longer has the cognitive capacity to understand the proceedings (major neurocognitive disorder). As of the date of the sources consulted, the judge had not ruled; any removal from the proceedings would concern him alone and not the other persons under investigation.

    Sources (2)
  6. Court decision

    Last two witnesses summoned for November

    Court proceedings

    Judge Alejandra Gil Lima summoned as witnesses, for 13 November 2026, Gerard López, former Barça B coach, who had stated publicly in February 2026 that he had received and used the reports, and the delegate Antonio Alonso.

    Sources (2)
  7. Court decision

    The judge refuses to extend the investigation phase

    Court proceedings

    The judge rejected the extension (decision of August 2026, made public on 1 September) at the 1 September 2026 deadline, but the investigation phase is not closed until the two November witness statements have taken place. An appeal by Real Madrid concerning investigative measures (diligencias) remains pending before the Audiencia.

    Sources (2)
  8. Ongoing

    UEFA receives a dossier from Real Madrid

    Investigation

    UEFA confirmed that it had received substantial documentation from Real Madrid, which will be examined by its inspectors in the investigation opened in 2023. FC Barcelona stressed that no new proceedings have been opened and that the UEFA proceedings depend on the outcome of the Spanish criminal case.

    Sources (2)
Points being verified 9

Items researched but not confirmed by a reliable source: they are not shown as facts in the timeline.

  • Exact date of the last payment (July 2018) — No reliable source consulted mentions July 2018; sources give 2018, linked to Negreira's departure from the CTA (May according to some, after June according to ESPN). Date kept at "year" precision.
  • Exact month in which Negreira took up his post at the CTA in 1994 — Only the year 1994 is documented (Fiscalía via elDiario.es, Catalan News).
  • Full breakdown of amounts by company over 2001-2018 (Dasnil 95, Nilsad, Soccercam) — Only the 2016-2018 period is broken down by company in the accessible sources; 2001-2018 totals range from €7.3m (Fiscalía) to €8.4m (Guardia Civil).
  • Outcome of the tax audit (regularisation, tax penalties for the club or Negreira) — No reliable source found on a final tax decision.
  • Judge's decision on Negreira's unfitness following the 2026 forensic medical report — Search of sources from June to October 2026: no decision found.
  • Date of any trial, opening of the trial phase (apertura de juicio oral) or general dismissal of the case — No reliable source; an estimate of a verdict at the end of 2027 comes from a site that was not used (africasoccer.com).
  • Current procedural status of Negreira's wife (money laundering) and of former executives Grau and Soler — They are listed as under investigation in 2025 (elDiario.es, 12 March 2025); no 2026 source specifies their status.
  • Complaint filed with FIFA ("Gravissimum") on 28 September 2026 — Single source (The Objective); author and admissibility not verified.
  • RFEF statement on joining the proceedings as a party (16 March 2023) — rfef.es page inaccessible (403); only the admission by the Audiencia (18 March 2024) is sourced.
Where the sources differ 8

Points on which the sources disagree; the timeline keeps the best-supported version.

  • Total amount: €7.3m (Fiscalía complaint), ~€7.5m (several media outlets), €8.4m (Guardia Civil report, December 2024); ESPN (2023) also mentions ~€6.65m excluding taxes.
  • SER revelation: ~€1.4m to Dasnil 95 (2016-2018) according to Infobae/Inside World Football; ESPN (2024) refers to €2.1m for the same period (probably including other companies).
  • End of payments: May 2018 (departure from the CTA) according to some sources, after June 2018 according to ESPN; July 2018 not confirmed.
  • Status of Joan Gaspart: witness according to elDiario.es and El Español, "investigado" according to Soccerway (not used).
  • Club's statement before the judge: scheduled for 27 January 2026 with vice-president Elena Fort, it took place on 10 April 2026 with treasurer Alfons Castro (EFE).
  • Date of Laporta's testimony: 12 December 2025 according to ESPN and elDiario.es; The Objective (October 2025) announced a summons in February.
  • 2026 forensic medical report: dated March 2026 by Infobae, made public around May 2026 (Iusport).
  • UEFA: The Objective's headline refers to a "reactivation" of the case; UEFA (via ESPN) and FC Barcelona speak of an investigation that has been ongoing since 2023.

Warning: Factual chronology compiled from press sources and official statements. All persons named are entitled to the presumption of innocence; no conviction exists as of the date indicated.

Statistics: before / during / after

Periods: before = 2000-01 (a single season), during = 2001-02 → 2017-18 (payments), after = 2018-19 → 2025-26. The study preset compares Barça and Real Madrid with a control group (Atlético Madrid, Valencia CF, Sevilla FC). Every other club also has its figures on its page, and the comparison tool lets you choose your own control group.

Points obtained − expected points per match

Based on the average pre-match odds (margin removed). Select a group to see its three periods.

Compare with another club

During = seasons 2001-02 → 2017-18.

Period

During · 2001-18

Selection

FC Barcelona

Deviation per match

+0.035

Before2000-01

−0.168

38 matches

During2001-18

+0.035

646 matches

After2018-26

+0.107

304 matches

Above the odds Below the odds
View page

Points and adjusted measures by period

Per match; strength-adjusted measures (positive = favourable to the club)

GroupPeriodMatchesPts − exp.pPenaltiesRedsYellowsFouls
FC BarcelonaBefore 2000-0138−0.1680.43−0.024−0.075+0.620—
FC BarcelonaDuring 2001-18646+0.0350.43+0.012+0.024+0.214+1.56
FC BarcelonaAfter 2018-26304+0.1070.11+0.004+0.031+0.034+0.85
Real Madrid CFBefore 2000-0138+0.2510.23+0.019+0.182+0.553—
Real Madrid CFDuring 2001-18645+0.0710.12+0.020−0.038−0.080−0.66
Real Madrid CFAfter 2018-26304+0.1380.05+0.036−0.013+0.249+1.74
Control groupBefore 2000-0138−0.0310.93+0.088+0.068−0.390—
Control groupDuring 2001-181,900+0.0540.06−0.005−0.004−0.169−0.97
Control groupAfter 2018-26912+0.0150.73−0.029−0.020−0.087−0.19
Atlético MadridDuring 2001-18608+0.0480.34+0.003−0.003−0.386−1.60
Atlético MadridAfter 2018-26304+0.1140.11−0.064−0.042−0.403−0.96
Valencia CFBefore 2000-0138−0.0310.92+0.088+0.068−0.390—
Valencia CFDuring 2001-18646+0.0530.28−0.042−0.020−0.269−0.89
Valencia CFAfter 2018-26304−0.0430.56+0.031+0.015+0.464+1.22
Sevilla FCDuring 2001-18646+0.0600.21+0.023+0.013+0.134−0.41
Sevilla FCAfter 2018-26304−0.0250.75−0.052−0.035−0.323−0.82

"Before": a single season of 38 matches, too few to draw conclusions. Hover over an adjusted value to see its confidence interval.

FC Barcelona

2001-18 → 2018-26, per match

Pts − exp.
+0.035 → +0.107
Penalties
+0.012 → +0.004
Reds
+0.024 → +0.031
Yellows
+0.214 → +0.034
2001-182018-26 (lime: favourable, lavender: unfavourable)

Real Madrid CF

2001-18 → 2018-26, per match

Pts − exp.
+0.071 → +0.138
Penalties
+0.020 → +0.036
Reds
−0.038 → −0.013
Yellows
−0.080 → +0.249
2001-182018-26 (lime: favourable, lavender: unfavourable)

Control group

2001-18 → 2018-26, per match

Pts − exp.
+0.054 → +0.015
Penalties
−0.005 → −0.029
Reds
−0.004 → −0.020
Yellows
−0.169 → −0.087
2001-182018-26 (lime: favourable, lavender: unfavourable)

Differences-in-differences

(A during − A after) − (B during − B after). Positive: A's advantage fell more after 2018 than B's.

ComparisonMeasureDiff-in-diff95% CIpqReading
Barça vs control groupPoints − expected−0.111[−0.256 ; 0.028]0.120.27no clear difference
Barça vs control groupPenalties (adjusted)−0.016[−0.091 ; 0.066]0.690.73no clear difference
Barça vs control groupReds (adjusted)−0.023[−0.087 ; 0.039]0.490.63no clear difference
Barça vs control groupYellows (adjusted)+0.262[−0.033 ; 0.549]0.080.24no clear difference
Barça vs control groupYellows, Zenodo series (adjusted)+0.322[−0.068 ; 0.690]0.100.27no clear difference
Barça vs control groupFouls (adjusted)+1.50[0.271 ; 2.759]0.020.08no clear difference
Barça vs Real MadridPoints − expected−0.006[−0.215 ; 0.183]0.950.95no clear difference
Barça vs Real MadridPenalties (adjusted)+0.024[−0.086 ; 0.128]0.650.73no clear difference
Barça vs Real MadridReds (adjusted)+0.019[−0.057 ; 0.091]0.620.73no clear difference
Barça vs Real MadridYellows (adjusted)+0.509[0.244 ; 0.776]< 0.001< 0.001notable deviation (q < 0.05)
Barça vs Real MadridYellows, Zenodo series (adjusted)+0.495[0.126 ; 0.886]0.0060.04notable deviation (q < 0.05)
Barça vs Real MadridFouls (adjusted)+3.11[1.528 ; 4.634]< 0.001< 0.001notable deviation (q < 0.05)
Real Madrid vs control groupPoints − expected−0.105[−0.281 ; 0.071]0.230.37no clear difference
Real Madrid vs control groupPenalties (adjusted)−0.040[−0.127 ; 0.055]0.370.55no clear difference
Real Madrid vs control groupReds (adjusted)−0.042[−0.111 ; 0.025]0.220.37no clear difference
Real Madrid vs control groupYellows (adjusted)−0.247[−0.582 ; 0.077]0.140.27no clear difference
Real Madrid vs control groupYellows, Zenodo series (adjusted)−0.173[−0.620 ; 0.239]0.430.60no clear difference
Real Madrid vs control groupFouls (adjusted)−1.62[−3.074 ; −0.099]0.040.14no clear difference

Club-season block bootstrap; q = Benjamini-Hochberg correction over the 18 tests. Yellow cards and fouls also depend on playing style (possession, pressing), which the odds adjustment does not capture. VAR and the end of the payments coincide in 2018-19.

Referee × club: verdicts, appointments, important matches

Summary of referee × club verdicts

All clubs, pairs with at least 5 matches (1,336 pairs)

MeasureTestedp < 0.05FavourableUnfavourableNo clear difference
Points − expected1,33649001,336
Penalty balance1,33637001,336
Red-card balance1,33648001,336
Yellow-card balance1,33662001,336
Foul balance1,24665001,336

Without correction, about 5% of tests fall below p < 0.05 by pure chance: that is the order of magnitude observed. After correction, no combination remains notable.

Appointment frequency

A club's matches assigned to a referee, observed vs expected

0notable out of 2,183 tested

Poisson test per referee × club combination, Benjamini-Hochberg correction. Details are on each pair page and in the "Referee × club" panel of referee pages.

Important matches

Are high-stakes matches assigned to certain referees more often? 2000-01 → 2025-26

Combinations tested

1,336

p < 0.05 before correction

53

q < 0.05 after correction

0

FC Barcelona: 54 referees (sorted by number of matches)
RefereeMatchesOf which importantShare (this referee)Share (other referees)pqReading
Undiano Mallenco501734%15%0.0010.33no clear difference
Mateu Lahoz411024%16%0.191.00no clear difference
Del Cerro Grande3626%17%0.101.00no clear difference
Gil Manzano36925%16%0.161.00no clear difference
Hernández Hernández35926%16%0.161.00no clear difference
David Fernández Borbalán35514%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Pérez Lasa31619%16%0.621.00no clear difference
Sánchez Martínez291035%16%0.020.93no clear difference
Martínez Munuera29414%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Ricardo de Burgos28414%16%1.001.00no clear difference
César Muñiz Fernández25728%16%0.101.00no clear difference
Fernando Teixeira Vitienes2528%16%0.411.00no clear difference
Iturralde González25520%16%0.581.00no clear difference
Carlos Clos Gómez23313%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Munuera Montero23313%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Carlos Velasco Carballo2229%16%0.561.00no clear difference
Manuel Mejuto González20630%16%0.121.00no clear difference
González González20420%16%0.551.00no clear difference
Javier Turienzo Álvarez20315%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Iglesias Villanueva1915%16%0.341.00no clear difference
Ramírez Domínguez19316%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Alfonso Pérez Burrull17953%16%< 0.0010.21no clear difference
Cuadra Fernández1700%16%0.091.00no clear difference
Luis Medina Cantalejo17424%16%0.501.00no clear difference
Delgado Ferreiro16319%16%0.731.00no clear difference
Bernardino González Vázquez16213%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Carlos Megía Dávila1500%16%0.151.00no clear difference
Soto Grado15320%16%0.721.00no clear difference
Jaime Latre1417%16%0.711.00no clear difference
González Fuertes1417%16%0.711.00no clear difference
Melero López1300%16%0.241.00no clear difference
Arturo Daudén Ibáñez1318%16%0.711.00no clear difference
Antonio Rubinos Pérez1318%16%0.711.00no clear difference
Julián Rodríguez Santiago1200%16%0.231.00no clear difference
Ayza Gámez1200%16%0.231.00no clear difference
Alberola Rojas12217%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Víctor Esquinas Torres11218%16%0.691.00no clear difference
José Losantos Omar1119%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Evaristo Puentes Leira1119%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Muñiz Ruiz1000%16%0.381.00no clear difference
Ortiz Arias1000%16%0.381.00no clear difference
José Paradas Romero900%16%0.371.00no clear difference
Pérez Montero9111%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Cordero Vega800%16%0.371.00no clear difference
Diaz de Mera7229%16%0.321.00no clear difference
Vicente Lizondo Cortés700%16%0.611.00no clear difference
Bikandi Garrido700%16%0.611.00no clear difference
Carmona Méndez7114%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Alfonso Pino Zamorano6233%16%0.251.00no clear difference
Antonio López Nieto6233%16%0.251.00no clear difference
José Antonio Teixeira Vitienes600%16%0.601.00no clear difference
Figueroa Vázquez600%16%0.601.00no clear difference
Mateo Busquets Ferrer6117%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Juan Luis Pulido Santana500%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Real Madrid CF: 50 referees (sorted by number of matches)
RefereeMatchesOf which importantShare (this referee)Share (other referees)pqReading
Undiano Mallenco521529%15%0.020.93no clear difference
Gil Manzano51510%16%0.321.00no clear difference
Martínez Munuera40820%16%0.511.00no clear difference
Mateu Lahoz40718%16%0.831.00no clear difference
Hernández Hernández37822%16%0.361.00no clear difference
David Fernández Borbalán37822%16%0.361.00no clear difference
Sánchez Martínez35926%16%0.151.00no clear difference
César Muñiz Fernández31516%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Iturralde González29517%16%0.801.00no clear difference
Carlos Clos Gómez28725%16%0.191.00no clear difference
Alfonso Pérez Burrull27933%16%0.031.00no clear difference
González González27311%16%0.601.00no clear difference
Pérez Lasa27519%16%0.791.00no clear difference
Fernando Teixeira Vitienes2628%16%0.411.00no clear difference
Soto Grado23522%16%0.401.00no clear difference
Ricardo de Burgos2329%16%0.561.00no clear difference
Ramírez Domínguez2215%16%0.231.00no clear difference
Manuel Mejuto González22523%16%0.381.00no clear difference
Javier Turienzo Álvarez1915%16%0.341.00no clear difference
Iglesias Villanueva1915%16%0.341.00no clear difference
Estrada Fernández19421%16%0.531.00no clear difference
Arturo Daudén Ibáñez19211%16%0.751.00no clear difference
Cuadra Fernández18211%16%0.751.00no clear difference
Luis Medina Cantalejo17529%16%0.171.00no clear difference
Munuera Montero1616%16%0.491.00no clear difference
Melero López1616%16%0.491.00no clear difference
Alfonso Álvarez1417%16%0.711.00no clear difference
Jaime Latre1417%16%0.711.00no clear difference
Alberola Rojas14214%16%1.001.00no clear difference
González Fuertes1300%16%0.241.00no clear difference
Delgado Ferreiro13215%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Julián Rodríguez Santiago13215%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Diaz de Mera1200%16%0.231.00no clear difference
Pérez Montero1100%16%0.231.00no clear difference
Carmona Méndez11327%16%0.401.00no clear difference
Bernardino González Vázquez10220%16%0.671.00no clear difference
Ayza Gámez10220%16%0.671.00no clear difference
Alfonso Pino Zamorano10110%16%1.001.00no clear difference
José Losantos Omar10110%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Antonio López Nieto8338%16%0.121.00no clear difference
Evaristo Puentes Leira8225%16%0.621.00no clear difference
José Antonio Teixeira Vitienes8113%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Javier Moreno Delgado6233%16%0.251.00no clear difference
Vicente Lizondo Cortés600%16%0.601.00no clear difference
Muñiz Ruiz600%16%0.601.00no clear difference
Mateo Busquets Ferrer6117%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Cordero Vega500%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Juan Ansuategui Roca500%16%1.001.00no clear difference
José Paradas Romero500%16%1.001.00no clear difference
Figueroa Vázquez500%16%1.001.00no clear difference

Important match: opponent in the season's final top 4 (recomputed standings: points, head-to-head, goal difference, goals scored), plus the Clásico for Barça and Real Madrid. Fisher's exact test per club × referee combination (at least 5 matches), Benjamini-Hochberg correction across all combinations, all clubs. Each referee's details are on their page.

Limitations

  • The odds reflect what the market knew before the match: a bias known to and priced in by the bookmakers would be underestimated.
  • Cards and fouls depend on playing style, which the odds adjustment does not capture.
  • The end of the payments and the arrival of VAR coincide (2018-19); matches behind closed doors in 2019-20 and 2020-21.
  • These tests deal with aggregate results. They say nothing about any specific decision in a match.

Redo the calculation with your own control group → · Methodology

Definitions

Expected points
Before each match, the bookmakers' odds give the probability of a win, a draw and a defeat. Expected points = 3 × P(win) + P(draw). A positive deviation means the club took more points than the market predicted. Because the team's strength is already built into the odds, a big club has no "automatic" positive deviation.
q-value
With hundreds of comparisons, some look extreme by chance. The Benjamini-Hochberg correction accounts for this: a deviation is only called notable if q < 0.05. Otherwise: no clear difference. No clear difference does not mean "no effect": with 11 matches, only a deviation of about ±1.57 points per match could have been detected.
Difference-in-differences
We measure the club's change between two periods, then subtract the change of a comparison group over the same periods. What remains is the change specific to the club.
Strength-adjusted measures
Each match is compared with Liga matches from the same season, at the same venue type (home/away) and between teams of comparable strength according to the odds. A positive value is favourable to the club.

Details in the methodology →