El ColegiadoData on refereeing in the Liga

Carlos Velasco Carballo × Athletic Bilbao

24 matches of Athletic Bilbao refereed by Carlos Velasco Carballo, from 2004-05 to 2015-16.

In short

Carlos Velasco Carballo has refereed 24 Liga matches of Athletic Bilbao, from 2004-05 to 2015-16: 8 wins, 7 draws and 9 defeats, a 33% win rate. With other referees, over the same seasons, Athletic Bilbao wins 37% of its matches.

  • Penalties won per match0.13opponents: 0.13 · with other referees: 0.17
  • Yellow cards received per match2.83opponents: 3.38 · with other referees: 2.50

Verdict: no clear difference once team strength is taken into account.

Once the strength of both teams is taken into account (using bookmakers' odds), the data show no clear difference with this referee.

Win rates do not account for the strength of opponents; the conclusion does.

Record

24matches

8 W7 D9 L

For / against, per match

Athletic Bilbao against its opponents, with Carlos Velasco Carballo

0.13
Penalties won
0.13
2.83
Yellows received
3.38
0.21
Reds received
0.13
17.3
Fouls called against
17.0
For experts: statistical tests and method

Comparison with bookmakers' odds, corrected p-values and appointments. Nothing is hidden: the full detail is here.

No clear difference does not mean "no effect": with 24 matches, only a deviation of about ±1.06 points per match could have been detected.

Points − expected points

−3.2pts over 24 matches

31 points obtained for 34.2 expected from the odds, i.e. −0.132 per match.

Points distribution from the odds

If only the odds mattered, over these 24 matches

Points obtained

31

Expected (odds)

34.2

Deviation

−3.2

two-sided p

0.66

Expected 34.2 ± 6.0 pts · probability of a deviation at least this large, in either direction: 66%.

Tests on the 5 measures

Deviation per match, raw p and corrected q (Benjamini-Hochberg, all pairs)

MeasureDeviationpqVerdict
Points − expected−0.1320.661.00no clear difference
Penalty balance−0.0141.001.00no clear difference
Red-card balance−0.0600.721.00no clear difference
Yellow-card balance+0.2830.481.00no clear difference
Foul balance−0.2190.871.00no clear difference

Appointments

The club's matches assigned to this referee, observed vs expected

Observed

24

Expected

32.1

p / q

0.17 / 1.00

no clear difference Seasons without a known referee for every match are not counted.

Matches per season

Number of matches (bars) and the season's points − expected deviation (hover)

Matches

The 24 matches

From Athletic Bilbao's point of view.

Date
Season2015-16
ScoreD1–1
Pen. for–against1–0
Yellows received–opp.2–5
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2015-16
ScoreD0–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.4–3
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2014-15
ScoreD0–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.5–6
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2013-14
ScoreW5–1
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.4–3
Reds received–opp.0–1
Date
Season2012-13
ScoreD1–1
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.4–1
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2012-13
ScoreL0–4
Pen. for–against0–1
Yellows received–opp.2–7
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2011-12
ScoreW3–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.2–4
Reds received–opp.0–1
Date
Season2011-12
ScoreL1–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.1–2
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2010-11
ScoreD1–1
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–4
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2010-11
ScoreW1–0
Pen. for–against1–0
Yellows received–opp.2–3
Reds received–opp.2–0
Date
Season2010-11
ScoreL1–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.2–3
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2009-10
ScoreW4–3
Pen. for–against1–0
Yellows received–opp.1–3
Reds received–opp.0–1
Date
Season2009-10
ScoreW2–1
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.6–3
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2008-09
ScoreL0–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–3
Reds received–opp.1–0
Date
Season2008-09
ScoreL0–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.1–4
Reds received–opp.1–0
Date
Season2008-09
ScoreW2–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–4
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2007-08
ScoreD0–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.4–6
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2007-08
ScoreL0–1
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.2–1
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2007-08
ScoreD0–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–2
Reds received–opp.1–0
Date
Season2006-07
ScoreW2–0
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–2
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2006-07
ScoreL4–5
Pen. for–against0–1
Yellows received–opp.4–4
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2006-07
ScoreW4–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.2–3
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2004-05
ScoreL3–4
Pen. for–against0–1
Yellows received–opp.2–4
Reds received–opp.0–0
Date
Season2004-05
ScoreL0–2
Pen. for–against0–0
Yellows received–opp.3–1
Reds received–opp.0–0
24 rows